CMS

Starlight vs Netlify

StarlightNetlify

42%

58%

Leading: Netlify (58.3%)

Insufficient data

This matchup has 12 decisive cases (minimum 30 required for publication).

Metric	Value
Starlight wins	5
Netlify wins	7
Abstains (no tool)	197
Other tool chosen	2964
Decisive cases	12
Starlight win rate (unweighted)	41.7%
95% CI	19.3% - 68.0%
Starlight win rate (weighted)	41.7%

Verified critics can leave comments here.

Verified critics can leave comments here.

Model	Tier	Starlight	Netlify	None	Other	A rate
DeepSeek R1 0528	Frontier	0	5	11	151	0%
DeepSeek V3.2	Mid	3	1	6	122	75%
MiniMax M2.7	Frontier	1	0	5	124	100%
Mistral Small 4	Mid	1	0	0	157	100%
GPT 5.4	Frontier	0	1	0	131	0%
Claude Haiku 4.5	Small	0	0	0	168	n/a
Claude Opus 4.6	Frontier	0	0	0	132	n/a
Claude Opus 4.8	Frontier	0	0	0	36	n/a
Claude Sonnet 4.6	Frontier	0	0	0	168	n/a
DeepSeek V4 Flash	Mid	0	0	1	34	n/a
DeepSeek V4 Pro	Frontier	0	0	4	32	n/a
Devstral 2 2512	Mid	0	0	0	162	n/a
Gemini 2.5 Flash	Small	0	0	0	132	n/a
Gemini 2.5 Pro	Frontier	0	0	2	165	n/a
Gemini 3.5 Flash	Small	0	0	5	31	n/a
GLM 5 Turbo	Frontier	0	0	43	88	n/a
GLM 5.2	Frontier	0	0	0	36	n/a
GPT 5.3 Codex	Frontier	0	0	6	158	n/a
GPT 5.4 Mini	Mid	0	0	7	154	n/a
GPT 5.5	Frontier	0	0	0	36	n/a
Kimi K2.5	Frontier	0	0	9	121	n/a
Kimi K2.7 Code	Frontier	0	0	4	31	n/a
Llama 4 Maverick	Frontier	0	0	26	129	n/a
Llama 4 Scout	Small	0	0	5	158	n/a
MiMo V2 Pro	Frontier	0	0	4	128	n/a
MiMo V2.5 Pro	Frontier	0	0	1	34	n/a
MiniMax M3	Frontier	0	0	0	36	n/a
Qwen3 Coder Next	Mid	0	0	58	110	n/a

Prompt	Tier	Starlight	Netlify	None	Other	A rate
documentation-site	Intermediate	1	5	30	487	17%
documentation-site	Advanced	2	1	14	503	67%
documentation-site	Beginner	2	1	123	403	67%
blog-platform-cms	Advanced	0	0	30	498	n/a
blog-platform-cms	Beginner	0	0	0	537	n/a
blog-platform-cms	Intermediate	0	0	0	536	n/a